Skip to main content
Write a Review, Win $500! Help guests by leaving a review of your favorite dishes. Be entered in a drawing to win $500 on 5/1.
Hugger-Mugger Tasty Recipes
  • Apply Today
  • Menu
  • Order Now
  • About
  • Gallery
  • Promotions
  • Call Us
  • Contact
    Send A Message
Bone-in wings

Menu

Become a VIPReceive updates on special events, new menu items, menu reviews, and more!

Menu

Add For Curb Side Pickup!!

10001

Add to order for Free Curb Side Pickup

PARK ON SIDE OF BUILDING FACING ARBYS IN CARRY OUT PARKING SPOT! WE ALSO HAVE 4 SPOTS ON THE PLAZA SIDE!! Please describe color, make, model of vehicle in special instructions!

10001
Order Online
Stuffed Chicken Breast
00000

Stuffed Chicken Breast

$9.49Chicken breast overstuffed with our seasoned stuffing and covered in Chicken Gravy. Served with 2 sides.

00000
00000

Gift Card

Add a gift card to your order and we will have it ready for you. 
Also for a fee we can ship one to the address you provide in the description below!
$10.00 $10$20 $20$50 $50$100 $100

00000
Order Online
Stuffed Pepper Dinner
00000

Stuffed Pepper Dinner

$9.49Peppers stuffed with Angus ground beef, spices, and rice. Served with two sides.

00000

Appetizers

Wings
20020

Wings

Bone, Boneless or Naked (White meat)

Sauce Options: BBQ | Ranch | Hot | Mild | Cajun | Garlic | Mauler | Honey Mustard | Hugger-Mugger | Hugger-Hot | Plain
Mini $5Small $9Medium $12Large $15

20020
Order Online
Cheezee Fries
00000

Cheezee Fries

A large order of lightly seasoned French fries topped with real crumbled bacon, mozzarella, and cheddar cheese.Regular $6Large $9.50

00000
Order Online
Zucchini Planks
00000

Zucchini Planks

A generous portion of flash-fried zucchini planks with dipping sauce.Regular $6Large $9.50

00000
Order Online
Tater Wedges
00000

Tater Wedges

Flash fried wedges lightly seasoned and topped with real crumbled bacon, mozzarella, and cheddar cheeses. Served with sour cream.Regular $4.50Large $8

00000
Order Online
00000

Chips & Salsa

$5Our House-Made Corn Tortilla Chips and House-Made Salsa

00000
Order Online
00000

Chicken Fingers

$6Homestyle breaded chicken tenders fried until golden brown. Served with dipping sauce.

00000
Order Online
Combo Platter
00000

Combo Platter

$9Combination of Chicken Finger, Tater Wedges, Mozzarella Sticks and Onion Rings

00000
Order Online
Mozzarella Sticks
11000

Mozzarella Sticks

Breaded mozzarella sticks flash-fried and seed with dipping sauce.Regular $6Large $9.50

11000
Order Online

Garden Fresh

Available Dressings: House Ranch | Zesty Italian | French | Sweet & Sour | Honey Mustard | Thousand Island | Bleu Cheese | Light French | Fat-Free Raspberry Vinaigrette | Balsamic Vinaigrette | Olive Oil Blend | Red Wine Vinegar

*All salad bases: Crispy Iceberg Salad Mix, Peppers, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, and a Hard-Boiled Egg

*Steak Salad
00000

*Steak Salad

Seasoned grilled sirloin, mozzarella cheese, and French fries.Regular $9.49Mini $7.99

00000
Order Online
Grilled Chicken Salad Supreme
10001

Grilled Chicken Salad Supreme

Tender strips of grilled chicken breast crumbled bacon, cheddar and mozzarella cheeses, and curly fries.Regular $9.49Mini $7.99

10001
Order Online
BBQ Ranch Chicken Salad
10001

BBQ Ranch Chicken Salad

Tender strips of Cajun seasoned chicken breast crumbled bacon, cheddar, and mozzarella cheeses with French fries, Latticed with BBQ and ranch dressing. What a treat!Regular $9.49Mini $7.99

10001
Order Online
Buffalo Chicken Salad
20011

Buffalo Chicken Salad

Crispy pieces of chicken coasted in Our Buffalo sauce, cheddar, and mozzarella cheese and French fries.Regular $9.49Mini $7.99

20011
Order Online
CF
00000

*Taco Crunch Salad

Our ground Angus Seasoned with taco seasonings, piled atop fresh tortilla chips, and topped with cheddar cheese.Regular $9.49Mini $7.99

00000
Order Online
Chef Salad
00000

Chef Salad

Smoked ham, honey turkey, cheddar, and mozzarella cheeses.Regular $9.49Mini $7.99

00000
Order Online
CF
*Bacon Cheeseburger Salad
00000

*Bacon Cheeseburger Salad

Our ground Angus, crispy bacon, mozzarella, and cheddar with French fries.Regular $9.49Mini $7.99

00000
Order Online
Gyro Salad
00000

Gyro Salad

Specially blended beef and lamb, curly fries, and mozzarella cheese.Regular $9.49Mini $7.99

00000
Order Online
CF
00000

Tuna Salad

Topped with fresh tuna salad.Regular $9.49Mini $7.99

00000
Order Online
00000

House Salad

$3.49Choose your dressing

00000
Order Online

Side Items

00000

French Fries

Large $2.99Regular $1.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Curly Fries

Large $2.99Regular $1.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Onion Rings

Large $4Regular $3

00000
Order Online
00000

Mashed Potatoes

$1.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Baked Potato

$1.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Cole Slaw

$1.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Apple Sauce

$1.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Cottage Cheese

$1.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Rice Pilaf

$1.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Extra Pita Bread

$1.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Bread Stick

$0.43

00000
Order Online
00000

Loaded Baked Potato

$3.49

00000
Order Online
00000

House Salad

$3.49Choose your dressing

00000
Order Online

The Sandwich Shop

Includes One Side (Excludes a Burgh Thing & Pittsburgher): French Fries | Curly Fries | Coleslaw | Cottage Cheese | Apple Sauce - Substitute Soup, Salad or Onion Rings - $1.50

Our Famous Reuben
00000

Our Famous Reuben

$8.50Tender corned beef sliced thin and smothered with Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and Thousand Island dressing on grilled rye bread.

00000
Order Online
A Burgh Thing N'at
00000

A Burgh Thing N'at

$9Choose your meat: Honey Turkey, Ham, Corned Beef, Ribeye. Served with Coleslaw, crispy French fries, Swiss cheese, and tomatoes piled high on our thick-cut Italian bread.

00000
Order Online
CF
Jumbo Battered Cod Sandwich
10001

Jumbo Battered Cod Sandwich

$9.99A Jumbo, white and flaky Cod filet battered and breaded in our special seasonings and flash-fried to perfection. Served on a toasted fresh hoagie roll with tarter sauce and lettuce.

10001
Order Online
CF
00000

Southwest Chicken Sandwich

$8.50Grilled chicken breast topped with crumbled bacon, BBQ sauce, and melted cheddar cheese. On a fresh baked bun topped with lettuce and tomato.

00000
Order Online
00000

The Country Cut BLT

$7.50A country favorite. Crispy bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, and mayo on your choice of thick-cut white, wheat, or rye toast.

00000
Order Online
00000

*The Pittsburgher Sub

$9Our signature patty with Swiss cheese, French fries, and coleslaw piled high on a toasted hoagie bun.

00000
Order Online
CF
Spicy Chicken Club
00000

Spicy Chicken Club

$8.50Boneless spicy breaded chicken breast flashed fried to a golden brown and topped with bacon strips, Swiss cheese, mayo, lettuce, and tomatoes. Served on a kaiser bun.

00000
Order Online
Bacon Chicken Ranch
00000

Bacon Chicken Ranch

$8.50Boneless breaded chicken breast flash-fried to a golden brown and topped with bacon strips and ranch dressing served on a kaiser bun with lettuce and tomatoes.

00000
Order Online

Hot Open Faced Sandwiches

Served with your choice of potato. (One Side Only)

00000

Open Face Turkey Breast

$7.50smothered with gravy

00000
Order Online
Open Face Pot Roast
10010

Open Face Pot Roast

$8smothered in gravy

10010
Order Online
*Homemade Open Face Meatloaf
00000

*Homemade Open Face Meatloaf

$7.50smothered in gravy or marinara

00000
Order Online

Subs, Melts & Pitas Toasted and More

All subs made cold, toasted, or as a melt.

Choose: Hoagie, Pita, White, Wheat, Rye or Texas

00000

Combo Club

$8.50Ham, Honey Turkey, Bacon, Swiss Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, and Italian dressing.

00000
Order Online
Ham & Cheese
00000

Ham & Cheese

$8.50Served with lettuce and tomatoes.

00000
Order Online
00000

Turkey Bacon Cheese

$8.50Served with lettuce and tomatoes.

00000
Order Online
00000

Tuna

$8.50Served with lettuce and tomatoes

00000
Order Online
Meatball Marinara
00000

Meatball Marinara

$8.50

00000
Order Online
20011

BBQ Ranch

$8.50Crispy Cajun seasoned chicken tenders topped with bacon, cheddar, and mozzarella cheese, BBQ and ranch dressing.

20011
Order Online
*Philly Steak and Cheese
00000

*Philly Steak and Cheese

$8.50Thinly sliced ribeye smothered with melted provolone, onion and green peppers.

00000
Order Online
10001

Chicken Philly

$8.50Tender Grilled marinated chicken slices smothered with provolone, onion, and green peppers.

10001
Order Online
Gyro
00000

Gyro

$8.50An authentic blend of lamb and beef with lettuce, onions, and tomatoes. Served with cucumber sauce on the side.

00000
Order Online
CF
00000

Veggie Delight

$8Cucumbers, Lettuce, Tomato, Mild Pepeprs, Green Peppers and Onion all topped with our ranch dressing.

00000
Order Online

Family Time Dinner Classics

Served with your choice of two sides, excludes Stir-Fried selections.

Available Sides: Baked Potato| Mashed Potatoes| French Fries | Curly Fries | Coleslaw | Cottage Cheese | Apple Sauce - Substitute Soup, Salad or Onion Rings - $1.50

Chicken Plank Dinner
10010

Chicken Plank Dinner

Tender strips of white chicken breast breaded and flash-fried to a golden brown, get them tossed in your favorite sauce for $1 more.Regular $8.99Senior Portion $7.29

10010
Order Online
Country Fried Steak
00000

Country Fried Steak

$8.99Country Seasoned beef patty breaded, flashed fried, and covered with creamy pepper gravy.

00000
Order Online
10001

Marinated Chicken Fillets

Tender chicken breast seasoned and grilled to perfection.Regular $9.49Senior Portion $7.29

10001
Order Online
CF
00000

*Liver & Onions

$8.49Tender beef liver smothered in grilled onions.

00000
Order Online
20002

Southwest Chicken

Grilled BBQ Chicken breast topped with crumbled bacon, cheddar, and diced tomatoes.Regular $9.49Senior Portion $7.49

20002
Order Online
00000

Smothered Chicken

Grilled marinated chicken breast smothered with fresh sauteed onion, peppers, mushroom, provolone cheese, and marinara sauce.Regular $9.49Senior Portion $7.49

00000
Order Online
00000

Country Fried Chicken Dinner

$8.99Tender Chicken breast breaded with your choice of country seasoned or spicy crispy goodness. Covered with our creamy pepper gravy and served with two sides.

00000
Order Online
New!
Stir-Fry
10001

Stir-Fry

$9.49Your choice of grilled chicken, steak, or veggie served atop, lightly seasoned vegetables and rice pilaf sauteed together. Served with one side.

10001
Order Online
00000

Fried Chicken

$9.49Country seasoned chicken breaded then fried to a golden brown, please allow 25 min, of cook time. No piece selection.

00000
Order Online
Homemade Meatloaf Dinner
00000

Homemade Meatloaf Dinner

Our own freshly made meatloaf covered in your choice of marinara sauce or a rich dark gravy.Regular $8.99Senior Portion $7.49

00000
Order Online
00000

Ham Steak Dinner

$9.49Our Honey Glazed Ham Steak Dinner, Served with 2 sides.

00000
Order Online

The Club House

Served on your choice of white, rye, or wheat toast with mayo, lettuce, and tomatoes. Includes one side: French Fries | Curly Fries | Coleslaw | Cottage Cheese | Apple Sauce - Substitute Soup, Salad or Onion Rings - $1.50

Turkey Bacon Club
00000

Turkey Bacon Club

$8Thinly sliced honey baked turkey and crisp bacon.

00000
Order Online
00000

Ham, Turkey & Cheese Club

$9.50Thinly sliced honey baked turkey, slices of smoked ham, and Swiss cheese.

00000
Order Online
00000

Ham, Egg & Cheese Club

$8Grilled Slices of smoked ham, scrambled eggs, and American cheese.

00000
Order Online
00000

The All American Club

$9.50Back by popular demand. Our signature burger served with grilled slices of smoked ham and American cheese.

00000
Order Online

Dockside Specials

Served with choice of two sides | Substitute Onion Rings or Soup - $1.50

Hand Breaded Cod Filet
10001

Hand Breaded Cod Filet

$9.99A large white fillet of cod breaded in our special seasonings.

10001
Order Online
Baked Cod Filet
00000

Baked Cod Filet

$9.99A large white fillet of cod baked in our special seasonings.

00000
Order Online
Clam Basket
00000

Clam Basket

$8.49A boast load of tender clams.

00000
Order Online
Maryland Crab Cakes
00000

Maryland Crab Cakes

$10.99A special blend of lump crab meat and seasonings hand-formed and grilled.

00000
Order Online
00000

Popcorn Shrimp Basket

$8.99Breaded shrimp, fried golden brown.

00000
Order Online
Seafood Platter
00000

Seafood Platter

$12.99Hand-Breaded Cod, a Maryland crab cake, shrimp, and clams with your choice of potato, a house salad, and bread stick.

00000
Order Online

Grilled Butcher Specials

Includes your choice of two sides and bread | Substitute Onion Rings or Soup - $1.50

00000

*USDA Choice Sirloin

$10.99Grilled, tender and seasoned.

00000
Order Online
Pork Chops
00000

Pork Chops

Two grilled 6 oz. boneless pork loin fresh-cut in a house with the choice of BBQ or simply lightly seasoned.Regular $9.49Senior $7.49

00000
Order Online
*Ground Steak
00000

*Ground Steak

$9.49Grilled seasoned ground steak covered with mushrooms and gravy.

00000
Order Online
*Steak & Chicken Combo
00000

*Steak & Chicken Combo

$10.99Best of both worlds! 6 oz. choice cut sirloin and a grilled chicken breast.

00000
Order Online
CF

Little Italy

Served with a hearty portion of spaghetti or pasta of the day, a salad, and breadstick.

Chicken Alfredo
00000

Chicken Alfredo

$9.99Tender strips of grilled chicken breast atop a bed of pasta sauteed in a rich and creamy Alfredo sauce.

00000
Order Online
00000

Spaghetti Dinner

Two homestyle meatballs served with pasta, marinara sauce, and mozzarella cheese.Regular $9.49Seniors $7.29

00000
Order Online
00000

Ravioli Dinner

Two homestyle meatballs served with cheese-filled ravioli, marinara sauce, and mozzarella cheese.Regular $9.49Seniors $7.29

00000
Order Online
Crusted Chicken Parmesan
00000

Crusted Chicken Parmesan

$9.99Grilled boneless chicken breast patty atop a choice of pasta or ravioli topped with toasted parmesan cheese.

00000
Order Online
00000

Veal Parmesan

$9.99Flash-fried veal patty atop a choice of pasta or ravioli topped with toasted parmesan cheese.

00000
Order Online
00000

Italian Sausage Casserole

$8.99Crumbled sausage served with sauteed pasta, marinara sauce, and mozzarella cheese.

00000
Order Online
00000

Meaty Pasta

$9.99Seasoned ground beef grilled with peppers and onions, served atop a generous portion of pasta. All covered in our marinara, mozzarella, and parmesan cheeses.

00000
Order Online

The Back-Yard Grill

Your choice of grilled 100% Angus or Hormone-free marinated chicken served on a fresh-baked bun. 100% Angus beef burgers with one side: French Fries | Curly Fries | Coleslaw | Cottage Cheese | Rice | Vegetable of the Day | Homefries | Apple Sauce

Substitute Soup, Salad or Onion Rings - +$1.50 | Garden Burger - +$0.75

00000

*Classic Burger

Our grilled patty topped with lettuce, tomato, pickle, and onions.Classic Burger $8Senior $6

00000
Order Online
*Deluxe Cheeseburger
10001

*Deluxe Cheeseburger

$8.50Choose from Swiss, American, provolone, mozzarella, or cheddar cheese

10001
Order Online
CF
*Beefy BLT
00000

*Beefy BLT

$9.50Take a classic BLT with bacon, mayo, lettuce, and tomatoes, and add big beefy layers of Angus beef on Texas toast.

00000
Order Online
*Bacon Cheeseburger
00000

*Bacon Cheeseburger

$9Two strips of bacon and a choice of Swiss, American, Mozzarella, or cheddar cheese on a kaiser bun.

00000
Order Online
CF
00000

*Breakfast Cheeseburger

$9.50Bacon and an over hard egg with Swiss, American, Mozzarella, or cheddar cheese.

00000
Order Online
00000

*Reuben Burger

$9.50Our Classic Burger smothered in sauerkraut, Thousand Island dressing, and Swiss cheese on grilled rye bread.

00000
Order Online
*Dante's Inferno Burger
00000

*Dante's Inferno Burger

$9Cajun seasonings, smothered in our hot wing sauce and topped with grilled jalapeno peppers and cheddar cheese.

00000
Order Online
*Mushroom & Mozzarella Burger
00000

*Mushroom & Mozzarella Burger

$9Mozzarella cheese and grilled mushrooms

00000
Order Online
00000

*BBQ Ranch Burger

$9Topped with bacon, cheddar, mozzarella, BBQ sauce, and ranch

00000
Order Online
MS (Mother Ship) Gut Buster
10001

MS (Mother Ship) Gut Buster

$10.50Two Grilled patties piled a mile high with lettuce, tomato, pickle, and onions served with your choice of cheese.

10001
Order Online
*Grilled Cheezzzzy Melt
00000

*Grilled Cheezzzzy Melt

$10Two American classics brought together. Our Angus burger sandwiched between two grilled cheese sandwiches then topped with lettuce, tomato, pickle, and onions.

00000
Order Online

Kids Meals

For our guests 12 and under. Includes one side(except pasta): French Fries, Curly Fries, Mashed Potatoes, Vegetables, Rice, Cottage Cheese, or Applesauce.

10001

Jr. Grilled Chicken

$3.99

10001
Order Online
00000

Jr. Cheeseburger

$3.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Cheese Pizza

$3.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Jr. Hot Dog

$3.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Jr. Fish

$4.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Jr. Grilled Cheese

$3.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Corn Dog

$3.99

00000
Order Online
10001

Jr Chicken Strips

$3.99

10001
Order Online
Jr Ham Dinner
00000

Jr Ham Dinner

$3.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Jr Meatloaf Dinner

$3.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Jr Soft Taco

$3.99

00000
Order Online
00000

Kids Spaghetti

$3.99Served with one meatball

00000
Order Online

Beverages

00000

Pepsi

$2.09

00000
Order Online
00000

Diet Pepsi

$2.09

00000
Order Online
00000

Coke

$2.09

00000
Order Online
00000

Diet Coke

$2.09

00000
Order Online
00000

Mountain Dew

$2.09

00000
Order Online
00000

Root Beer

$2.09

00000
Order Online
00000

7 Up

$2.09

00000
Order Online
00000

Dr. Pepper

$2.09

00000
Order Online
00000

Raspberry Iced Tea

$2.09

00000
Order Online
00000

Fresh Brewed Iced Tea

$2.09

00000
Order Online
00000

Sweet Tea

$2.09

00000
Order Online
00000

Lemonade

$2.09

00000
Order Online
00000

Green Tea

$2.09

00000
Order Online

Dessert

00000

Cheese Cake

$5.50Save room for a generous slice of our home-made creamy delicious cheese cake.

00000
Show All Items
CFCustomer Favorite
New!New!

Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness.

Made with by Popmenu

Location

New Castle2650 Ellwood Road New Castle, PA 16101(724) 652-5155paul@huggermuggertastyrecipes.com
Monday - Sunday: 6:00 am - 10:00 pm
Hugger-Mugger Tasty Recipes
Website Accessibility Assistance
Opens in a new windowOpens an external siteOpens an external site in a new window